Commentators have put either China or the US or both in the frame as the nations that ultimately sank the chances of a comprehensive climate agreement at Copenhagen.
Two commentaries published in the Guardian newspaper in the past week give some insight into the power politics being played out at the very top in climate negotiations and what was driving the leadership of two superpowers at the meeting.
Judge for yourself:
China sank the dealMark Lynas writes:
“China wrecked the talks, intentionally humiliated Barack Obama, and insisted on an awful "deal" so western leaders would walk away carrying the blame. How do I know this? Because I was in the room and saw it happen…”
Read the full story
The US sank the dealGeorge Monbiot writes:
“The immediate reason for the failure of the talks can be summarised in two words: Barack Obama…”
Read the full story [scroll to last six paragraphs]
Was it both? Does it matter?Ultimately, one thing is clear, concerted global climate action can’t take place without both the US and China:
Carbon Positive's view
